英语家园

 找回密码
 注册

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

扫一扫,访问移动社区

搜索

当老人摔倒了,您会上前搀扶吗?

发布者: katy | 发布时间: 2010-12-14 07:47| 查看数: 3795| 评论数: 8|

Would you help if an old people falls down?

2006年,南京老太徐寿兰赶公交时跌倒,路过市民彭宇将她扶起就医。事后法院认定“彭宇与徐老太相撞

可能性较大,应赔偿徐寿兰40%治疗费”。这就是有名的“南京彭宇案”。

In 2006, Peng Yu helped an old woman named Xu Shoulan who fell down when running for the bus

to go to the hospital. Then the court concluded that "it was likely that Peng Yu had

collided with Ms Xu and he should compensate 40% of the treatment cost of Xu Shoulan". This

is the well-known "Case of Peng Yu in Nanjing"

2008年,一位七旬老太摔倒在重庆市南坪东路星宇花园门口的人行道上。这位七旬老太路边摔得头破血流

,虽然很多市民关心她,但却始终无人敢上前搀扶,一市民拨打120急救电话后着急离开,被众人一致留

下:“你不要走,走了我们怕说不清楚。”



In 2008, an 70-year-old woman fell down onto the sidewalk at the gate of Xingyu Garden,

Nanping E.Road, Chongqing. Her head was beaten and bleeding. Many citizens were concerned

about her health, but nobody dared to offer help. A citizen dialed 120 for emergency

services and then hurried to go, but he was stopped but the crowd saying " You can't go,

otherwise, we may be hard to explain".

“一个老太太倒下去,千万个人躲开来,红灯停绿灯行,遇见老太太要绕行!”我们不得不承认,“不敢

搀扶”已经成为道德“潜规则”。即使是好心人、热心人也存在“不敢搀扶”的问题,这难道是“道德风

险”吗?如今在大马路上,要有老人摔倒,你还会搀扶吗?

" When an old woman falls down, everyone strikes aside. Stop at red light, proceed at green

light and back away from old women." We have to admit "not daring to help" has become the

"hidden rules" of virtue even for those kind and warm-hearted people. Is it "virtue risk"?

Now, when an old person falls down on the road, will you help?

欢迎大家跟帖说出你的看法(尽量用英语),或者加入我们的全英语QQ群参与讨论。英语家园全英语超级QQ群群规:

https://www.enfamily.cn/thread-3723-1-1.html

最新评论

R-Tracy 发表于 2010-12-14 08:31:46
To be honest, I dare not offer help when an old person falls down on the road. Last month I was at home and saw an old man tripped over on the road. Minutes later,he sat up with his forehead bleeding. My heart sank andfelt so sorry for him but I could do nothing. I hate to be cold-blooded, but who would prove me innocent if I went and offered help to him?

评分

参与人数 1鲜花 +20 收起 理由
katy006688 + 20

查看全部评分

20550514 发表于 2010-12-14 09:23:48
what should i choose when i suffer this kind of condition?it depends on what kinds of that condition.that's not all the old people like Xu Shoulan.as a word said:i'd like to let the world become better as I exist.so I shall offer help what I can insofar as I am able.

评分

参与人数 1鲜花 +20 收起 理由
katy006688 + 20

查看全部评分

mind_bay 发表于 2010-12-14 11:21:30
ifi think the oldman have the ability to stood up i will not do thatifhe have not,i will dono matter what will happen 我的英语很差 如果说的有错 希望有哪位热心朋友帮我纠正 万分感谢 thankyou so much

评分

参与人数 1鲜花 +20 收起 理由
katy006688 + 20

查看全部评分

ZWRing 发表于 2010-12-14 12:42:16
{:soso_e176:}

I'm so sorry I'm afraid I cann't offer help.We are trying to protect ourself not to be damaged by the baddy.
地瓜-河北 发表于 2010-12-14 17:29:16
Yes,I do
凯旋城 发表于 2010-12-15 09:23:01
i feel sorry to say i m afraid i wouldn't help in this case, unless in a special circumstance.

this reflects that there must be sth wrong with concerned laws, that our morailty standards have degraded. we have spared no effert in developing the economy but ignored ethics construction.

on the one hand , it s high time we should restrengthen morality education. on the other hand, much needs to be done to improve our legal system to protect the legitimate interests of those who do good deeds.
vofeima 发表于 2010-12-19 21:39:54
Front of the facts tell me, when disaster struck, help came from all sides. it concerns the responsibility and moral terms, as he catch a bus when it fell and put her up, it is right. but now, and legal consciousness increased. an old lady fell, thousands of people go to a stop lights from green, met an old lady want to make a detour. we have to admit that, not daring to help has become a moral "diving rule". and there "does not dare to help" confusion.
ninahu8008 发表于 2011-1-21 09:31:51
回复 4# mind_bay

If I were in this situation, i would give the old a hand. I do believe the majority is kindly and grateful.

The old saying"A burnt child dreads the fire", I hope people can desert this kind of social stereotypes.

Everyone will become old, if we were the old man/woman, what would we hope bystanders to do?
快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表